Mistaken Identity

Mistaken Identity

With Mila Kunis and Sarah Hyland

By Georgiou

Disclaimer: this story is pure fiction and none of this event has ever happen and none of action represents the person(s) involved. This story is just fan fiction and for your enjoyment only. Don’t repost anywhere else. Don't read if you're underage.

It was the night of the Screen Actor Guild Awards and I was there with my date Mila Kunis who recently got out of a long term relationship. She faked a smile on the carpet to avoid any questions about her past relationship. Once she was done and we headed inside, she pulled me aside.

"Thanks for doing this. The media won't stop over what happened"

I couldn't help but admire her body and the beautiful red dress she was in. I deeply wanted to be the guy to take it off her tanned body but that was nothing more than a fantasy.

"No problem, I can't let this get to you and how many guys can say they went to a red carpet event with Mila fucking Kunis."

She giggled

"Now, I see why you really said yes. You wanted me. You want me really bad?"

I shrugged my shoulders.

"Maybe, you can't blame me for wanting to. You're unbelievably sexy. Any man would want you."

She laughed.

"Just keep it in your pants and we see after."

As I spoke to Mila, her Black Swan costar Natalie Portman walked up to us. She wore a long white dress. I couldn't help but stare till Mila nudged me.

"Mila, we got present in about an hour. You won't mind if we go over the script?"

Mila nodded and told her "Sure". Then she turned to me.

"Hey George, I have to take care of this. I'll find you afterward." She said as she walked away with Natalie.

I grabbed myself a drink and mingled with various famous guests. I found myself in a conversion with TV mom Sofia Vergara from Modern Family. She was one of those exotic older ladies I would love to take in the heat of the moment.

Unfortunately for me, I never had my opening to make a move before we were interrupted by her show's producer. She left me there with unfulfilled desire. My only option was to find my date Mila Kunis.

I noticed a petite brunette in a red dress head upstairs towards the washroom, I followed her to a secluded area and I pushed the washroom door open and saw her.

 She had just wiped her hands dry when I came up behind her and grabbed her ass while I cupped her right breast. She started to scream but I covered her mouth.

"Calm down Mila. It's me"

She bit my hand and turned around.

"Mila? I'm not Mila. You, pervert I should turn you into security."

My eyes almost popped out my head as I just groped the wrong girl. She looked familiar but I couldn't remember where I had seen her from.

 I was about to explain myself when I heard footsteps. I grabbed the girl and covered her mouth and pulled her into a stall.

"Just be quiet and I'll explain" I whispered in her ear. She nodded and mumbled under my hand.

I heard the door open and heels click against the floor. A voice called out.

"Sarah, are you in here?"

I whispered in her ear if she's Sarah to answer her.

"Yeah Ariel, I'm just finishing up"

"Alright, they wanted me to find you. They want you back in 15 minutes"

"Okay, thanks" the brunette said.

I heard the door open and the sound of the other girl's heels slowly faded.

"Sarah is it? Look this big misunderstanding. From behind you looked like Mila. No one needs to know. I'll do anything to keep this between us."

She thought it over. She was annoyed about what just happen but she was excited and turned on by experience.

"Anything? I always had a fantasy to have a stranger fuck me in public place. My boyfriend tried to role-play this but it’s not the same. You gave me the thrill I wanted especially when we were almost caught by my co-star"

I couldn't believe how horny this teen star was. I couldn't believe my ears about what she wanted. I wanted Mila but Sarah is great replacement.

Sarah didn't waste any time. She unzipped my pants and fished out my cock. She put her hands on my lap as she moved onto her knees on the bathroom floor.

She stroked my cock till it was fully erect. Her wet mouth encased my length as she worked her mouth on it.

Her tongue wet my shaft as she sucked and slurped on my cock. Her eagerness to a suck off a stranger in a bathroom showed.

 Her hand slipped under her hiked up dress and I could see her fingers in her wet pussy.

Her tongue licked the head of my cock. I couldn’t wait and pushed head down on my shaft so her head was in my lap. I heard her gag and cough before I released my grip.  As soon as I did, she splat out my dick.

"You fucker, I almost choked." She said

I shrugged my shoulders and pulled her onto my lap where I impaled her tight pussy. Her eyes widened at my sheer side inside her. She started to bounce on my lap. Her legs slapped against mine every time she came down on my cock.

"That it, take it. Such a slut, wanting to fuck a stranger in the bathroom" I laughed

I pumped my cock up into her tight and wet pussy. She got loud and I had to cover her mouth to keep her quiet. I didn't want to be caught like this. The "Modern Family" star couldn't hold out any longer from the assault on her pussy and she came and I felt her juice seep onto my shaft

"Oh fuck" she said

I pushed her back onto her knees and forced my cock between her soft lips. I pumped my cock in and out of her mouth till I unleashed my seed down her throat. She coughed and split out some of my cum. She licked up the rest around her lips before she got off the bathroom floor.

"Thanks, I'm Sarah. We should do this again" she said as she fixed dress and hair. I nodded and she left the bathroom.

I couldn't believe what just happen. An unexpected encounter in washroom with who might have been Sarah Hyland. I wasn't 100% sure that it was her but I didn't care. I knew I had to find Mila after that encounter.

I returned to the main hall where the awards were being presented and at the microphone were Mila Kunis and her Black Swan costar Natalie Portman. By the screen behind them, they were set to present the award for best ensemble in a comedy series. I saw the winner were the cast of Modern Family.

Thou it did confirm that it was in fact Sarah Hyland that I did fuck in the bathroom earlier. As I watched I hoped Sarah didn't talk to Mila but she did. I could see Sarah whisper something into Mila's ear. Mila headed towards me once she was done on stage.

"I heard the most interesting piece of gossip. You had mistaken Sarah for me and groped her in the bathroom?"

"Um... um." I was speechless. I didn’t know what to say.

"You couldn't wait? You want me that bad? You would fuck me in the bathroom?"

I shrugged my shoulders

"What can I say? She is sexy and it just happened."

She had a confused look on her face

"Wait? You're telling me that you fucked Sarah. She didn't tell me that. You do know she has a boyfriend"

"Sarah didn't tell you everything?" I laughed

"Um, no. Looks like Sarah isn't that innocent either"

Mila couldn't help but laugh.

"No she’s not but I wonder about you. Are you a good girl or do you love a raw dirty fuck like a naughty girl?"

The former "That 70's show" star was shocked by what I had just asked. She was speechless. She just pulled aside to a more deserted spot of the hall.

"As much I love that idea. I don't know if I can. I'm flattered you're interested or at least want my body but I just got out a long relationship and the break up was tough."

I couldn't say I wasn't disappointed that I had no shot even after I had agreed to be her date. So she can avoid the media frenzy. She went back to a group of friends while I went to bar to drown my sorrows.

I turned around a fist hit my face. It knocked me back and caused me to drop my drink.

"What the hell"

I rubbed my cheek and looked at semi tall guy with black hair. I hadn't recognized his face. So I punched him back and we got into a brawl before Mila and Sarah ran over to break up the fight once they got wind of the fight.

“Baby calm down, it didn’t mean anything." I heard Sarah say to the other guy.

Mila held me back to stop me. I pushed Mila aside and took a cheap shot at the other guy and nailed him on the bridge of his nose. Security soon intervened and threw me and other guy out. Mila and Sarah soon followed us.

"What the hell" he said

"You hit me first. You don't blindside a guy." I fired back

"You also don't sleep with another man's girlfriend."

"Oh you're Sarah's boyfriend. Sorry dude it just happened and she wanted it."

He rubbed his face.

"Only way to make this even is that I sleep with your girlfriend"

I shrugged my shoulders.

"Sure, if I had one"

"What about her?"  He pointed to Mila Kunis

“I wish but Mila isn't my girlfriend. I wish she was."

"Really, rumors are that you two are a couple."

Mila laughed

"We're not Matt, but that is what we wanted people to think so people didn't ask me about my recent break up."

"Well it worked" he laughed

"Look dude if I could make up to you I would but Mila is saying no to me."

Mila cut in

"Well maybe I can change my mind. If Sarah joins in, so the four of us can have a great night"

Sarah thought it over

"Come on babe. You want to spice things up so another couple will do that?"

"Well I always found you sexy Mila. I just never experimented with another girl."

"Don't worry. I will be gentle" Mila said

Sarah nodded and agreed and the four of us left for their L.A. home.

Once we had arrived we headed down to their large basement. Mila has whispered in my ear that if I did exactly what she told me to do to Sarah; she'll let me fuck her. An offer I couldn't turn down, I just couldn't let Sarah wear me out despite our earlier encounter that night.

Matt helped his girlfriend out of her dress; she stood there in nothing but her black bra and panties.

"So Sarah you say you enjoyed your experience earlier why don't you suck his cock" Mila turned to me and told me strip and take a seat on the couch.

I followed what she told me to do and Sarah came over and wrapped her lips around my hard cock. Her boyfriend came up behind her and unhooked her bra and slid her panties down her legs.

He felt up her ass as her rubbed her pussy. Her moans vibrated around my cock as she slurped and suck on my piece of meat. Mila stood there to direct traffic as me and Matt fucked the petite brunette from both ends.

Her mouth and pussy were filled with cock as Mila watched on but I call her over and reached my hand under her dress to rub her now wet pussy. It seemed to me that scene in front of her turned her on.

With both her mouth and pussy stuffed, Sarah moaned around my cock till she split it out. She gasped for air because of my length. Mila waste little time to remove her dress and moved her panties aside to impale herself on my saliva coated dick.

"Oh fuck" she said

Her warm wet pussy was tight as it hugged and squeezed my shaft. She bounced on my lap; the sight of young stars in front of us turned her on.

I thought it was a dream when the former "That 70's show" star rode my cock. She furiously bounced up and down as my dick thrust in and out of her. Sarah watched on in amaze.

“Love that Sarah? Thinking of earlier or of Mila's pussy." I laughed as she blushed.

"Maybe we should give her a taste." Mila threw this smile my direction before she got off my lap and spread her legs open for the young actress who portrayed Haley Dunphy.

Sarah pulled away from her boyfriend to bury her face in the older girl's pussy. Matt and I watched how much slut Sarah could be.

"Close your mouth, you're drooling."

As he watched in stunned mode, I walked over and pushed my cock passed the lips of the exotic Ukrainian beauty. My pole vibrated in her mouth because of her moan. Sarah hungrily ate the older girl's pussy.

"I think it is safe to say your girlfriend loves pussy" I commented to Matt who responded with a laugh.

I grabbed Mila's face and started to fuck her mouth which caused to her moan louder and even scream. I let go and pulled out as she gasped for air.

“Oh! Fuck that was hot, I love the feel of her tongue" Mila said as she to cum in her face.

Sarah licked up and cleaned Mila's pussy of her juices and cum. Matt signaled to his girlfriend to move so he can fuck the "Black Swan" star's pussy. His cock pumped in and out her while Sarah watched on.

She was still on her hands and knees; I took a good look at her cute ass before I stuffed her unexpected asshole with my cock. Her eyes almost popped out of her head as she cried out in pain.

"Ow! Take it out. It hurts. Please!" She begged

"I didn't hear that. Take it out of where?"

"My ass, take it out of my ass!

"Okay"

I slowly pulled out till I heard the pop but I shoved my cock balls deep right back into her ass. I slammed my cock in and out of her stretched out hole. She cried out in pain and tears rolled down her face. I continue to sodomize the "Modern Family" star's asshole.

"Hey! Stop that, you're hurting her" Her boyfriend Matt called out.

I jammed my fingers into her wet pussy and doubled the pleasure as she sobbed.

"Her pussy tells me otherwise. She loves it, she just doesn't know it"

"Please stop, take it out"

I pounded her adorable ass and finger banged her pussy in attempt to make her cum from the double assault on her holes. I finally hit a nerve and her cried of pain turned into moans of pleasure.

"Oh fuck! That the spot"

She moaned out loudly as I drilled her ass.   Her moans grew in volume till she came all over my fingers. I withdrew my throbbing shaft from her ass.

I looked over to see Matt already showered Mila in his cum so I stroked mine and was about to cum on Sarah but she stopped me.

"Cum inside me, I love the warm feeling"

I shoved my cock into her pussy and I pumped my cock inside her till I unloaded my hot seed deep inside her wet pussy. She pulled out and my cum seeped out her she cleaned it up with her fingers.

Mila came over and sucked the excess cum off my dick till I was dry; she swallowed a mixture of mine and Matt's cum. I rested on the ground. I couldn't believe that this just happened.  I was the real winner this night; I got Mila like I want and Sarah was quite the added bonus. This ended a night that I never forget. I was sure if Mila wasn't over her break up before she was now.